10 June 2005 (Friday)

not even close

I woke up this morning to a report on the news saying that Sacred Heart Catholic Church in Weymouth had suffered a devestating fire overnight. It's terribly sad when any place of worship and community gathering is damaged or destroyed, and this is even more poignant because there were to be weddings today and tomorrow in the historic building. My sympathy goes out to the entire community, who until now had probably felt incredibly lucky to retain their "home" during the recent wave of church and school closings.

But...in the car on the way to work this morning, I continued listening to the news and heard a snippet of an interview with the church's cantor (I didn't even know they had those). And what did she say? "I looked at the church and it reminded me of September 11th."

Now, I can't fault you for being reminded of something. You have no control over the inner workings of your subconscious mind. I can, however, get righteously pissed at you for saying that out loud. No matter how precious a place of worship is, it is still nothing more than a building. One firefighter was seriously injured, but as far as I know, no one was killed.

I have no idea how you compare this to nineteen maniacs taking over four airplanes full of innocent people, and then proceeding to crash those planes into large buildings full of other innocent people (though failing as to one plane). How do you compare a seeing the aftermath of a church fire to watching people jumping hand-in-hand with their coworkers from the hundreth floor of a burning office building. How do you compare the smoky air around an extinguished fire to the concrete dust and charred bits of human flesh that wafted over Manhattan for nearly a week, causing residents as far as six miles away to shut their windows lest they choke on the fumes (or, at least, the thought of what they were smelling).

So, please, I know you can't always help what you're thinking, but maybe sometimes you should keep your thoughts to yourself.

# posted by shanna at 9:01 AM
TrackBack URL for this entry:
honorable mentions
Universal Hub mentioned not even close on 10 June 2005 at 11:32 AM in "Unfair comparison":

Shanna is saddened by the devastating fire at Sacred Heart Church in Weymouth, but can't believe the church's cantor compared the fire to 9/11:

... No matter how precious

comments

Agreed. I really hope that as time passes, 9/11 doesn't start getting used in the shameful way that the Holocaust has been used in recent decades, as an easy catch-all metaphor for anything wrong with the world.


Posted by: Alisha at 10:28 AM on 10 June 2005

Dear Shanna,

Thank you for these remarks. (I just discovered your blog jumping from the RenReb's comments).


Posted by: Rebecca at 10:59 AM on 12 June 2005
post a comment









remember personal info?

Due to spam problems, I have installed a comments filter. Sometimes legitimate comments are filtered out and must be manually approved. Sorry for the inconvenience.